Are you going to argue with an album that contains the line, "I still feel more at home with these mutts?" I'm not.
Tin Armor play pop-punk with heart-on-sleeve-without-sacrificing-intelligence lyrics. Matt plays the drums. Matt plays guitar, vocals and keyboards. Matt plays bass and vocals. They aren’t the same guy. I wonder, do they spend a lot of time saying, "What?", or all running when somebody calls, or do they employ a call-us-by-our-last-names system? Or do they call each other by their instruments, and does that give the guy who plays keyboards and guitars an indentity crisis? Sure all the songs sound sort of the same, but so do all punk songs, so what does anybody care? They sing pretty. They play piano sometimes. They know how to write a hook and put vocal harmonies together.
I also won't argue with the line, "But I won't kiss this evil way anymore."